Just when you thought the hard part was over.
You’ve successfully managed to to talk your kid into learning an instrument and even settled on one that he said that he wouldn’t mind learning: guitar. You’re excited because you see guitar as one of those “lifetime” instruments that he will be able to play for the rest of his life. He’s excited because today is the day that you both are going to the music store to let him pick out a guitar. You drive to the store, get out of the car, walk in the door and ask the salesperson “I’m looking for the guitars.” He slyly points over his shoulder toward what can only be described as a “wall of guitars” and as your kid grabs your hand and begins to drag you in that direction, you ask yourself a simple question: “What have I gotten myself into?”
Just when you thought the hard part was over.
Has this ever been you?
The guitar-buying process can be stressful and confusing and without a competent and trusted friend or sales associate guiding you through the process, it can feel overwhelming and almost paralyzing. In one area you see thin, colorful guitars that look like something Eric Clapton or Jimi Hendrix played and in a whole other section, sometimes in a room by themselves, you see fatter, wood-colored guitars that look like the guitar that James Taylor or David Crosby played.
Suddenly uncertainty anxiety engulf whatever optimism you had left about trying to buy a guitar today and the questions start to clog up the traffic in your brain like an overturned tractor-trailer on the highway.
Questions like:
…”Why are these guitars in a different area?”
…”Why are these guitars thinner than the other ones in that room?”
…”Which one of these is the ‘Beginner’ guitar?”
…”Why is the room spinning?”
In order to help you keep from having a similar situation when YOU go to the music store to buy your kid his first guitar, I’ve come up with a simple “Guitar Buying Guide” that will take you through some of the more confusing and difficult steps of the guitar buying process. The goal of sharing some of these tips with you is to arm you with confidence and keep you from feeling overwhelmed when you approach the “wall of guitars.”
And we are starting today where most people start when they walk into a music store and are directed toward the guitar area and have to decide between the “wall of guitars” (Electric) or the “room of guitars” (Acoustic). The format will be a simple “Frequently Asked Questions” format with a question and then an answer underneath it. Remember, the goal is not to turn you into an expert or to even help you outsmart one of the store employees, but to simply arm you with confidence as you help your kid not only learn to play an instrument, but hopefully fall in love with music. Let’s get started.
A C O U S T I C V S . E L E C T R I C
1. What’s the difference between the two?
An electric guitar typically has a solid body and needs to be plugged into an amplifier or alternate source (computer) to be played and heard. An acoustic guitar, while it can be plugged in like an electric guitar, typically has a hollow body and can be played without being plugged in and still retains the integrity of its intended sound.
2. Which is a better “starter” guitar?
Determining which guitar is a better depends on a few different variables and is not as simple of an answer as choosing one or the other. Below I will have a pro/con answer for each type, but here I will answer that question with a question of my own. Why does your kid want to play guitar? If your kid wants to play the guitar because he sees people playing the electric guitar and he wants to do what they do, then get your kid an electric. If he sees people playing an acoustic guitar and wants to be like them, then start him on acoustic. Getting your kid to practice and improve as a guitar player is already an uphill battle in itself, so make sure that you’re starting him off on the right foot by including him in the buying process. When in doubt, ask your kid.
3. Is the acoustic guitar a good guitar for a beginner?
First of all, because of the way it is built, an acoustic guitar is a good guitar for beginners because it can be picked up and played in a matter of seconds and requires no additional equipment to plug into or connect to. It has great mobility so if your kid wants to practice in his room one day and on the porch the next, he can do it relatively easily without having to move anything but his guitar. Because of this, however, the strings on an acoustic guitar are a little thicker and require more pressure on them (by your kid’s fingers) to get a good sound out of them. This can create more fingertip pain for your kid than if he were playing an electric (which would still cause some pain) and if not managed properly could become a reason why he might consider quitting down the road.
The difficulty however, which could be a deterrent for some, can actually be an advantage if he would ever want to switch to learn to play an electric guitar at some point later in the learning process. Many guitarists will say that the physical act of playing an electric guitar is easier than playing an acoustic and your kid will be more likely to attempt a switch if he is going from hard to easy than if he was going from easy to hard. The thing to assess is whether or not your kid has the physical strength or the desire to work through the process of pressing the strings down until it sounds good. If so, then an acoustic might be the place to start.
To check out the article I wrote about helping your kid deal with finger pain, CLICK HERE!
4. Should I start my kid out on an electric guitar?
One of the reasons that the electric guitar is great for beginners is because it is so easy to play. While the chords and the notes are not necessarily any easier, the guitar itself, because of how close the strings are to the neck and because the strings themselves are actually thinner, the physical act of practicing and playing the guitar is easier. With finger pain being a major issue that beginning guitar students deal with, the simple act of being easier and less of a roadblock to mastery might be enough for you and your kid to decide that the electric guitar is the place to start.
One of the major drawbacks of learning to play on an electric guitar is that to get a true sound of what the guitar sounds like, you will also need to get your kid some sort of amplifier and an instrument cable (that will connect the guitar to the amplifier.) The “amp” is not just a tool to make the guitar louder (it does do that), but it also (depending on the amp that you get) can give the guitar different sounds and can even help your kid feel like what he is playing sort of sounds like the music he listens to on his iphone. They can be somewhat expensive, but if your kid truly wants to learn to play the electric guitar, then the extra cost might be a worthwhile expense if it means your kid is going to work hard and stick with it.
5. Which guitar did I start out on?
When I was twelve years old, my dad (a guitar guy) bought a new Fender Stratocaster and offered to teach me on it. Because it was an electric guitar, the playability was there, but the interest was nowhere to be found. Sadly, three chords and two weeks later, I was officially done learning to play guitar.
Fast forward six years later and I’m getting ready to begin my freshman year of college. For some reason, I ask my dad if I can take his black Epiphone acoustic guitar to college with me so I can actually learn to play guitar. Given my history with the guitar, he was understandably skeptical about my work ethic and made a deal with me that if I took the guitar and learned how to play, he would give it to me; straight up. But if I didn’t learn to play the guitar, then he was going to take it back and sell it.
For me, learning to play the guitar was less about the kind of guitar and was all about the environment in which I learned. As a kid, I was practicing upstairs on a couch by myself fumbling between the “E” and the “A” chords. But as a college student, I was surrounded by guys on my hall who had guitars and some of them actually knew how to play them! They helped me learn by showing me where to place my fingers on the frets and giving me sheet music to work from. To this day, thirteen years later, I still have yet to learn to play the electric guitar. I have a really nice one that, one again, my dad generously bought for me, and I’m sure at some point, I’ll get it out and learn how to play.
6. Cute story, but seriously, which guitar is a better starter guitar for my kid?
If you can help your kid maneuver through the initial difficulty of playing and up the steep learning curve, I would recommend an acoustic guitar as the guitar that you buy for your kid to start out on. Outside of tuning it (every time), it is as simple as picking it up and playing. No cords, just chords.
But again, deciding between an acoustic and an electric guitar essentially comes down to which guitar is your kid more likely to fall in love with. Have a few conversations with him, ask him a few questions, and once you get to the music store you’re not playing “Let’s Make a Deal” as much you’re playing “Love Connection.”
More than recommending a style of guitar, I recommend building and developing a relationship with the guitar guys (or girls) at your local music store. Bring your kid in and meet them and let them help you find a guitar that not only fits your kid physically, but emotionally. It’s even a good idea to see if they have a money-back guarantee or a 100% value trade-in policy so that if for some reason it doesn’t work out with a certain style or model, you might have a chance to take it in and find something that might be a better fit for your kid. Ultimately, whichever style gets your kid excited about practicing and learning to play is the right one.
In your experience, which one of these is a better guitar for a beginner?